What Are Business Rules in Software Development?

We’ve made some changes! DhiWise’s Requirement Builder and Project Planner are no longer available, as we’re bringing you something even better. Now, you can plan, build, and launch your software projects in one simple flow with

DhiWise

In modern software development, business rules serve as the backbone of decision-making and process automation. These predefined rules guide applications in executing tasks, ensuring that every action aligns with business objectives, industry regulations, and user expectations.

For instance, an e-commerce platform may have rules about discount eligibility, a banking system may enforce transaction limits, and a healthcare platform may define rules for patient data access.

But what are business rules in software, and why do they matter? In this blog, we will explore:

✅ How to define business rules effectively.

✅ Best practices for business rules documentation.

✅ The importance of business rules in ensuring software accuracy and compliance.

By the end, you’ll have a complete understanding of how business rules impact software functionality and how to implement them efficiently.

What Are Business Rules in Software Development?

Define Business Rules

A business rule is a condition or guideline that governs how software should operate in specific situations. It ensures that all actions follow predefined business logic, making the software more structured, compliant, and error-free.

Example of a Business Rule

• Loan Application System → "A loan applicant must have a credit score of at least 700 to qualify for a personal loan."
• E-commerce Discount Rule → "Apply a 10% discount if the customer has spent $500 or more in the last month."

Business Rules vs. Business Logic

Many developers confuse business rules with business logic, but they serve different purposes:

Business rules provide flexibility by allowing rule changes without modifying the core software code.

Types of Business Rules in Software Development

Understanding the different types of business rules is essential for defining them correctly. Here are the four main types:

✅ Operational Business Rules

Define the day-to-day operations of a system. Example: “A customer must be at least 18 years old to create an account.”

✅ Constraint Business Rules

Establish boundaries for system actions. Example: “A transaction limit of $10,000 applies to non-verified accounts.”

✅ Derivation Business Rules

Define calculated values based on existing data. Example: “Sales tax is calculated as 10% of the total order value.”

✅ Trigger Business Rules

Define event-driven actions. Example: “Send an email notification when an order is placed.”

Each type ensures software operates correctly, consistently, and efficiently.

Why Are Business Rules Important?

Business rules play a critical role in ensuring software reliability. Here’s why they are essential:

✅ Ensuring Consistency → Prevents human errors in decision-making.

✅ Improving Compliance → Helps businesses meet regulatory requirements (e.g., tax laws, security policies).

✅ Enhancing Flexibility → Business rules can be updated without changing software code.

How to Define Business Rules in Software Development

Defining business rules in software development is a crucial step to ensure that the software operates in alignment with business goals and policies. Here’s a breakdown of the process with detailed explanations for each step.

Step 1: Identify Business Requirements

Understanding the Rules Needed for Your Application Before you start creating business rules, you must first understand the business needs and the context of the software you're developing. The goal here is to identify specific conditions under which certain actions need to take place in the software.

How to Identify Business Requirements:

Collaborate with Stakeholders:

• Business analysts, project managers, and clients should provide a clear picture of the business needs.
• Understand how the business functions and what rules need to be automated within the software.
• For example, in a ride-sharing app, stakeholders might emphasize the need for rules around ride cancellations (e.g., charges for late cancellations).

Understand Legal and Compliance Needs:

• Certain business rules might be related to compliance requirements, such as ensuring that software adheres to legal regulations (e.g., GDPR in Europe, HIPAA in healthcare).
• A financial application might have rules regarding transaction limits or fraud detection.

Assess Existing Systems:

In some cases, you may already have legacy systems that have defined processes or rules. Understanding these processes will help guide the new business rules.

Example:

• Let’s take a ride-sharing app as an example. You’d start by understanding business requirements such as:
• Rules about ride cancellations, where a passenger may cancel a ride but could be charged a cancellation fee after a certain time period.
• Discount policies for frequent riders. Eligibility requirements for drivers based on their vehicle type or driver ratings.

Why it’s Important:

Identifying business requirements ensures that you don't overlook critical elements and helps you align the software with real-world business operations.

Step 2: Create Simple, Clear Rules

Write Rules in a Structured Format Once you understand the business requirements, the next step is to translate them into actionable, clear business rules. These rules should be easy to understand, both for developers implementing the rules and for business teams who will use them to guide decisions.

How to Create Simple, Clear Rules:

Use Plain Language:

• Avoid jargon. Write rules that anyone, including non-technical business stakeholders, can easily comprehend.
• Use condition-action statements, such as: "If [condition], then [action]". This is a simple format that is easily interpretable.

Ensure Consistency:

• Define how each rule will be structured (e.g., decision tables, flowcharts) to ensure consistency across the entire system.
• Keep the rules unambiguous and free of contradictions.

Ensure Completeness:

Make sure the rules cover all possible scenarios. Don’t leave gaps or situations where the rule doesn’t apply. Example: For an e-commerce platform, a simple rule might look like this: "If an order exceeds $50, apply for free shipping within the U.S."

This rule is easy to understand and can be directly translated into system logic, like calculating whether the customer is eligible for free shipping.

Why it’s Important:

Creating clear and simple rules is vital to ensure that there is no confusion or ambiguity when the rules are applied to the software. Well-defined rules will help the development team to implement them correctly and make the system more reliable and transparent.

Step 3: Validate & Test

Ensure Accuracy by Testing the Business Rules Before Deployment Once the business rules have been defined and documented, it is crucial to validate and test them to ensure they work as expected in different scenarios. Testing is important because errors in business rules can lead to faulty business operations or poor user experiences.

How to Validate and Test Business Rules:

Unit Testing:

• Test each rule individually within the application to ensure that it behaves as expected under different conditions.
• Use automated tests to verify that the rule behaves as intended in various use cases (e.g., order value > $50 triggers free shipping).

Integration Testing:

• Ensure that business rules interact correctly with other parts of the system. For example, ensure that rules like "apply discount if eligible" don't conflict with order processing systems or payment gateways.

User Acceptance Testing (UAT):

• Have real users or business stakeholders validate that the rules are aligned with real-world scenarios and that they meet business expectations.
• For example, ensure that the ride cancellation policies in a ride-sharing app are implemented in a way that passengers and drivers both find fair.

Edge Case Testing:

Test business rules in edge cases (e.g., a borderline age of 18 for user registration or a transaction of $9,999). This ensures that the system behaves correctly even in unusual or rare cases. Example:

For the rule in the e-commerce platform example:

• You would write tests to check whether orders over $50 automatically receive free shipping, and orders below $50 do not.
• You'd also test whether the shipping cost updates correctly when the order value changes due to items being added or removed.

Why it’s Important:

Validating and testing business rules ensures that the rules work in real-world scenarios, are free of errors, and are fully functional in the application. It minimizes the risk of operational disruptions after the software is deployed.

By following these three steps—identifying business requirements, creating clear and simple rules, and validating and testing—you ensure that the business rules embedded in the software meet the business objectives and user needs while providing flexibility and scalability for future growth. Properly defined and tested business rules lead to more reliable, maintainable, and compliant software.

Business Rules Documentation and Management

Effective business rules documentation ensures that rules are:

✅ Easily accessible to developers and business teams.

✅ Consistently applied across the software.

Best Practices for Business Rules Documentation

• Use structured formats like decision tables, flowcharts, or rule catalogs.
• Maintain a centralized repository (e.g., Google Docs, Notion, BRMS).
• Ensure easy access for developers, business analysts, and QA teams.

A Business Rules Management System (BRMS) helps automate and store business rules efficiently.

Business Rules vs. Hardcoded Logic: Which One to Use?

Hardcoded logic is efficient for simple applications, but business rules provide better scalability and flexibility.

How to Implement Business Rules in Software?

Implementing business rules in software can be done in several ways, depending on the complexity of the application and the required flexibility. Here's a deeper look into three key methods:

1️⃣ Using Business Rules Engines (BREs)

Business Rules Engines (BREs) are specialized systems or software tools that automate the execution of business rules within an application. BREs are designed to separate business logic from application code, which provides several advantages, such as easier rule management, faster updates, and less clutter in the main application code.

How BREs Work:

• Rule Repository: Business rules are stored in a central repository, which makes them easy to manage and modify without altering the core application code.
• Execution: When a specific condition is met (e.g., an order exceeds $100), the BRE automatically triggers the corresponding business rule (e.g., apply a 10% discount).
• Separation of Concerns: BREs decouple the business rules from the main codebase, enabling non-technical users (business analysts) to define and manage rules without involving developers.

Example BREs:

• Drools: An open-source BRE that supports complex rule definitions. It is widely used in large-scale enterprise applications, where rules need to be dynamic and complex.
• OpenRules: A low-code Business Rules Engine that focuses on decision management, making it easier to implement business rules through a simple interface.

Benefits of Using BREs:

• Flexibility: Easily modify or add rules without changing the application code.
• Consistency: Ensures that the rules are applied uniformly across various parts of the application.
• Scalability: BREs can manage large rule sets efficiently and scale with growing business needs.

When to Use BREs:

BREs are ideal for large, complex applications where rules change frequently, or where non-technical users need to manage the rules (e.g., business analysts managing discounts, tax rates, etc.).

2️⃣ Embedding Rules in Code

Embedding rules in code means directly integrating business rules into the application's source code. This approach works well for simple applications where the rules are not expected to change often or become too complex.

How This Method Works:

• Hardcoded Logic: Rules are written directly in the code, often as if-else statements, loops, or other conditional checks.
• Quick and Simple: This approach is fast to implement for small-scale projects where the rule set is relatively static and does not require frequent updates.

Benefits of Embedding Rules in Code:

• Simplicity: Simple to implement for small applications with fewer business rules.
• Performance: Hardcoded rules are generally faster than rules executed through a BRE, as there’s no overhead of interacting with an external engine.

When to Use Embedded Rules:

Embedding rules is best suited for small, simple applications or cases where business rules are unlikely to change often. For example, a small internal tool with basic validation logic might be a good candidate for this approach.

3️⃣ AI-Powered Business Rules

AI-Powered Business Rules refer to the integration of machine learning and AI algorithms into the process of business rule definition and execution. This method uses data to help the system dynamically adapt to new business rules as they evolve over time.

How It Works:

• Data-Driven Decision Making: AI can analyze historical data, customer behavior, or real-time events to modify business rules based on patterns or emerging trends.
• Dynamic Adaptation: Machine learning models can automatically adjust business rules based on the input data and results, without needing to manually update them.

Example:

• In a fraud detection system for financial applications, AI can continuously learn from transaction patterns and dynamically adjust the threshold for flagging suspicious activities:
• The system can learn that fraud attempts increase on certain days or during specific hours, and adjust rules accordingly.

Benefits of AI-Powered Business Rules:

• Dynamic Adaptation: AI models continuously improve and adapt to real-time data, which makes business rules more effective and responsive to changes.
• Automation: Machine learning can automate complex decision-making processes that would be difficult for human rule writers to anticipate.

When to Use AI-Powered Rules:

AI-powered business rules are useful in data-rich environments where the rules need to evolve as more data becomes available or where complex decision-making is required, such as fraud detection, dynamic pricing, or personalized marketing.

Case Study: How DhiWise Helps

DhiWise, a software development platform, enables developers to define and manage business rules with efficiency. DhiWise simplifies the implementation of business rules by offering tools that integrate them seamlessly into the development process. This low-code approach allows developers to focus on the more complex parts of the application while streamlining business rule implementation.

DhiWise makes it easier for developers to incorporate and modify business rules quickly, without requiring deep technical knowledge, which accelerates software development cycles.

Common Challenges in Business Rules Implementation

While implementing business rules can significantly improve software quality, it does come with several challenges. Below are the most common issues developers face when implementing business rules in software systems:

❌ Complex Dependencies

Managing interconnected rules can become increasingly difficult as the number of rules grows. Some business rules might depend on others, and changes to one rule might affect multiple parts of the system, making it challenging to maintain.

Challenges with Dependencies:

• Cascading Effects: A small change in one rule can affect a chain of dependent rules. For example, changing a tax calculation rule might affect how discounts are applied, payment gateways are processed, and reports are generated.
• Rule Conflicts: As rules evolve over time, they might end up conflicting with each other, leading to inconsistent behavior.

Solutions to Mitigate Dependency Issues:

• Use a centralized rule repository or BREs to manage and track dependencies more effectively.
• Use decision tables or flowcharts to clearly visualize rule relationships and their interdependencies.

❌ Performance Issues

As the number of business rules grows, the execution time can increase, which can slow down application performance, especially for complex business rule sets.

Performance Challenges:

• Rule Execution Time: With large rule sets, the time it takes to process each rule can increase, affecting the overall performance of the application, especially if rules are being applied in real-time (e.g., fraud detection in financial apps).
• Overhead in BREs: While Business Rules Engines provide flexibility, they introduce overhead due to additional processing to evaluate and execute each rule.

Solutions to Improve Performance:

• Optimize Rule Execution: Use caching or batching mechanisms to reduce unnecessary re-evaluations of the same rules.
• Use Efficient BREs: Choose a BRE that’s known for high performance and capable of managing large rule sets efficiently.

❌ Scalability Concerns

Ensuring that business rules can scale efficiently across multiple platforms and handle increasing amounts of data or complexity is a significant concern.

Scalability Challenges:

• Multiple Platforms: Business rules must work consistently across various platforms, such as web, mobile, and backend services, which can introduce complexity in rule management.
• Growing Data Sets: As the amount of data increases (e.g., user actions, transactions), business rules need to be able to handle the larger volumes without degrading performance.

Solutions to Scalability Challenges:

• Cloud-Based Solutions: Leverage cloud-based Business Rules Management Systems (BRMS) to provide scalable storage and execution capabilities.
• Microservices Architecture: Implement rules in a distributed architecture, where each service or microservice can independently manage its own set of business rules, thus improving scalability and maintainability.

While business rules implementation brings numerous benefits, it’s important to be mindful of the challenges related to complex dependencies, performance issues, and scalability concerns. By adopting the right tools (e.g., BREs, cloud platforms) and strategies (e.g., caching, microservices), these challenges can be mitigated to ensure that business rules remain efficient, scalable, and maintainable.

Take A First Step to Build Modern Software with Better Decision-Making Capabilities

Business rules form the foundation of modern software decision-making. With proper business rules documentation, companies can ensure scalability, flexibility, and compliance in their applications.

Key Takeaways:

✔️ Use a structured approach to define and document business rules.

✔️ Choose business rules over hardcoded logic for scalability.

✔️ Leverage AI, BRMS, and automation for efficient rule management.

By implementing the best practices outlined in this guide, businesses can enhance their software performance while ensuring it meets industry standards and regulations. 🚀

Why the change? At DhiWise, we always want to make your journey easier. As new ideas and needs came up, we decided to grow too — from just helping you plan your project to helping you build the whole app! Today, DhiWise is your partner from the first idea to the final launch, making everything quicker, simpler, and more exciting. Learn more about

DhiWise

— where ideas take off faster.